What has changed three years in
The first phase of the Duty was about implementation: fair value assessments, governance, board reports and new MI packs. That work answered the question "have we put the Duty in place?"
The question has moved on. In its July 2026 review the FCA assessed board reports and information request responses from firms of different sizes and sectors, and surveyed 56 firms. Its message is that firms should be able to explain four things:
- What their information tells them.
- How they use it to identify risks or issues.
- What action they take in response.
- How they consider whether those actions have improved outcomes.
This applies across all four Duty outcomes: products and services, price and value, consumer understanding, and consumer support. Trade bodies are making the same point. The chief executive of the Association of Mortgage Intermediaries wrote in Mortgage Strategy this month that the emphasis now needs to shift towards impact.
Implementation MI and outcomes evidence
Most Duty MI packs still lean towards implementation evidence. The difference looks like this:
- Implementation MI counts activity: files reviewed, training completed, fair value assessments signed off, complaints closed in time.
- Outcomes evidence shows what the customer experienced at a stage of the journey, compared with a stated good outcome, and what changed when the result was poor.
A file review completion rate of 100% says the reviews happened. It does not say whether customers understood their product, got suitable advice or received support when they needed it. In one of the FCA's good practice examples, a firm defined good outcomes for each key product at stages such as joining, using the service and leaving, and linked these to its customer journeys.
What the FCA found missing
The review lists the gaps that stop MI from evidencing outcomes:
- Activity used as a proxy. Some firms used metrics like conversion rates or review completion without defining good or poor outcomes at each stage of the journey.
- Thresholds with no stated basis. Many firms set thresholds but could not explain how they indicated good or poor outcomes. The stronger examples explained why each threshold was meaningful for identifying potential harm.
- No trail from MI to action. Some firms collected relevant MI but could not show what they considered, where they challenged it, what they decided, when they acted or how they assessed the impact.
- Remedies not tested. The FCA says a new tool or checklist, by itself, "does not necessarily show that customer outcomes have improved".
- Aggregated vulnerability MI. Some firms reported vulnerability as one figure rather than splitting it by drivers such as health, financial resilience or life events.
- Boards that approve but do not challenge. In many cases boards focused on reviewing and approving reports rather than challenging them or pushing for further action.
Five tests to run on your own MI
Take each indicator in your current Duty MI pack and ask:
- Which outcome does it evidence? Name the Duty outcome and the journey stage. If you cannot, it is activity MI.
- Why is the threshold where it is? Write down the basis: past performance, a benchmark or a reasoned judgement about harm.
- What happened the last time it breached? Find the decision, the owner, the date and the action in your records.
- Did the action work? Show the indicator before and after, or a re-test of sample files against the expected improvement.
- Can it be split? Check whether the result differs for customers with characteristics of vulnerability, and by product or channel.
File checks can feed several of these tests. A file review pass rate is activity MI. The reasons files fail, grouped by root cause and tracked over time, are closer to outcomes evidence, because they show where customers may not have been given suitable advice or the right information.
Proportionate for smaller firms and distribution chains
The review allows for proportion. It says smaller firms "could use a focused set of indicators without complex systems or large teams". Good practice examples used complaints, customer feedback, missed service standards and file checks, with a simple log of issues, agreed actions and deadlines held by a senior individual.
Responsibility does not move with outsourcing. The FCA says firms using third parties to deliver part of their services "are still responsible for their customers' outcomes". For a network or lender, that means MI on outcomes delivered through appointed representatives and brokers, not only its own staff.
PRIN 2A.9.8R says a firm "must regularly monitor the outcomes retail customers receive". Under PRIN 2A.8.4R, the governing body reviews and approves the board report "at least annually". Our guide to the Consumer Duty board report covers how that report comes together, and preparing for an FCA Consumer Duty review covers the wider evidence file.
Where file checking is the bottleneck, Curvestone checks every case against a firm's own compliance criteria and flags gaps with evidence references, so root causes can be tracked across all files rather than a sample.
Frequently asked questions
What are the four Consumer Duty outcomes?
How many metrics should Consumer Duty MI include?
Do file review results count as outcomes evidence?
Consumer Duty board reports: the 12-cell evidence grid
A Consumer Duty board report is the assessment a firm's board must review and approve at least annually, evidencing the outcomes retail customers received across the four outcomes and three cross-cutting rules. The FCA's 2026 observations show most reports evidence too few of the twelve outcome-by-rule cells the Duty requires.
How toHow to prepare for an FCA Consumer Duty audit
An FCA Consumer Duty audit is the annual board-attestation cycle in which UK regulated firms must evidence good customer outcomes against the four outcomes and three cross-cutting rules of the Duty. The next Year-2 board report is due 31 July 2026, and the FCA's April 2026 observations require substantive evidence across all four outcomes.

Dawid Kotur
CEO and co-founder, Curvestone
Dawid co-founded Curvestone in 2024 after a decade working at the intersection of financial services and applied machine learning. He writes about the strategic direction of regulated-industry AI, the FCA's evolving approach to model risk, and the operational changes UK lenders are making in response to Consumer Duty. He sits on the FCA Smart Data Accelerator advisory cohort.
LinkedIn