Why brokers ask this
The question usually comes up when a compliance-support contract is due for renewal. A sole adviser at a UK directly authorised mortgage broker put it this way: "It would be better if we could replace that with something that was more hands on and more kind of moving on a kind of ongoing basis."
A director at another directly authorised broker made the point about responsibility. Whatever support the firm buys, the direct authorisation, and the FCA's questions, stay with the firm.
What an annual audit does well
A good annual audit is a useful control. It gives you:
- an independent view from someone outside the firm
- an in-depth review of a sample of files against the rules
- a check of policies, registers and training and competence records
- findings and actions you can take to your board
Its limit is time. A case submitted in February with a missing affordability note may not be looked at until the next visit, and only if it falls in the sample. By then the same gap may have repeated across dozens of cases.
What the rules ask between audits
Three parts of the FCA Handbook matter here.
Policies and procedures. SYSC 6.1.1R says a firm "must establish, implement and maintain adequate policies and procedures sufficient to ensure compliance" with its obligations under the regulatory system. For firms like mortgage brokers, SYSC 6.1.3AG asks them to take account of the compliance function rule as guidance. That rule describes a function that will "monitor and, on a regular basis, to assess the adequacy and effectiveness" of those procedures.
Monitoring outcomes. PRIN 2A.9.8R says a firm "must regularly monitor the outcomes retail customers receive" from the products it distributes, its communications and its customer support. The monitoring has to show, among other things, "whether retail customers are equipped with the right information to make effective, timely and properly informed decisions". Under PRIN 2A.9.11R, a firm "must have in place processes to identify the root causes" of any failure to deliver those outcomes.
The board report. PRIN 2A.8.3R requires a report "setting out the results of its monitoring under PRIN 2A.9 and any actions required". Under PRIN 2A.8.4R, the governing body reviews and approves it "at least annually".
None of this sets a number of files to check. PRIN 2A.9.3G says the frequency of monitoring "depends on the type of firm and its role in the distribution chain, the nature of the product, and the target market". The test is whether you can show regular monitoring, and what you did with it. Our guide to the Consumer Duty board report covers how that evidence comes together.
Responsibility stays with the firm
Buying compliance support does not buy out the responsibility. Where a firm outsources critical or important operational functions, SYSC 8.1.6R says it "remains fully responsible for discharging all of its obligations under the regulatory system". The same rule says the outsourcing "must not result in the delegation by senior personnel of their responsibility".
A compliance-support firm can advise, review files and report findings. The directly authorised firm decides what to do about them and answers for the result.
What ongoing file checking can look like
For a small directly authorised firm, ongoing checking does not need a compliance department. It needs a routine:
- Check every case before submission against your own checklist: required documents present, fact-find complete, a recorded reason linking the recommendation to the customer's needs, and affordability and vulnerability addressed.
- Record what each check found and what the adviser did about it.
- Review the record each month. Which checks fail most often, for which advisers, on which case types? That pattern is the root-cause view the Consumer Duty asks for.
- Give the record to your auditor. The annual visit then tests your monitoring instead of being your monitoring.
- Use the same record in your board report, alongside the audit findings.
Sampling a few files a month is better than waiting a year, but it still leaves most cases unseen. Our post on why spot-checking case files was a workaround sets out that trade-off.
Questions to ask before renewing compliance support
- How many of our files did the last audit review, and how were they picked?
- What do we know about the cases it did not review?
- Could we show the FCA our monitoring of customer outcomes for the last three months?
- Does our board report draw on our own monitoring, or on the audit report alone?
- If the auditor finds a pattern, can we tell how long it has been going on?
Curvestone checks mortgage case files before submission. Every document in the case is read and checked against compliance criteria, the gaps are flagged with evidence references, and the same checks run on every case. For a directly authorised broker, that gives a record for each case between audits, and the annual audit can then test the whole. To see how it works, book a call or a demo.
Frequently asked questions
How often should a directly authorised broker check its files?
Does outsourcing compliance support move responsibility to the provider?
Can an annual audit feed the Consumer Duty board report?
Spot-checking case files was a workaround, not a strategy
Sampling around 10% of mortgage files was never a judgement about risk. It was what a team could afford when each review took up to two hours. Now that every case can be checked, a sample sized by reviewer hours is a choice not to look at most of the book, and a firm should defend it as one.
DefinitionConsumer Duty board reports: the 12-cell evidence grid
A Consumer Duty board report is the assessment a firm's board must review and approve at least annually, evidencing the outcomes retail customers received across the four outcomes and three cross-cutting rules. The FCA's 2026 observations show most reports evidence too few of the twelve outcome-by-rule cells the Duty requires.

Dawid Kotur
CEO and co-founder, Curvestone
Dawid co-founded Curvestone in 2024 after a decade working at the intersection of financial services and applied machine learning. He writes about the strategic direction of regulated-industry AI, the FCA's evolving approach to model risk, and the operational changes UK lenders are making in response to Consumer Duty. He sits on the FCA Smart Data Accelerator advisory cohort.
LinkedIn